Forward-link scheduling in a wireless communication system

ABSTRACT

A method and apparatus for selecting a favored transmission slot for communicating non-voice data in conjunction with a voice-data communication. The slot, reflecting a favored power level and transmission rate for transmitting the non-voice data on a supplemental channel, is selected based upon the transmission power levels for voice-data transmitted by a base station to a remote station on a fundamental channel. The favored transmission slot is selected without the remote station messaging information to the base station concerning frequency channel or interference information for the supplemental channel. A method of performing forward-link scheduling in a wireless communication system includes determining the available base station power at the beginning of a frame, predicting the required transmit power at the beginning of the frame for each supplemental channel, determining rates sustainable with the predicted transmit power, dividing by throughput over a recent window to obtain a supplemental channel priority index, and allowing the supplemental channel with the highest priority index to transmit over the next frame.

CLAIM OF PRIORITY UNDER 35 U.S.C. §120

The present Application for Patent is a Continuation of patent application Ser. No. 09/528,235 entitled “FORWARD-LINK SCHEDULING IN A WIRELESS COMMUNICATION SYSTEM” issued Dec. 12, 2004, which is a Continuation in Part of Patent No.: U.S. Pat. No. 6,621,804, issued Sep. 16, 2004, and assigned to the assignee hereof and hereby expressly incorporated by reference herein.

REFERENCE TO CO-PENDING APPLICATIONS FOR PATENT

The present Application for Patent is related to the following co-pending U.S. Patent Applications:

“Forward Link Scheduling in a Wireless Communication System”, having Attorney Docket No. 990525B1C1, filed concurrently herewith, assigned to the assignee hereof, and expressly incorporated by reference herein.

BACKGROUND

1. Field

The present invention relates to wireless communications. More particularly, the present invention pertains to methods and apparatus for performing forward-link scheduling in a wireless communication system.

2. Background

Traditionally, wireless communication systems were required to support a variety of services. One such communication system is a code division multiple access (CDMA) system which conforms to the “TIA/EIA/IS-95 Mobile Station-Base Station Compatibility Standard for Dual-Mode Wideband Spread Spectrum Cellular System,” hereinafter referred to as IS-95. The use of CDMA techniques in a multiple access communication system is disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 4,901,307, entitled “SPREAD SPECTRUM MULTIPLE ACCESS COMMUNICATION SYSTEM USING SATELLITE OR TERRESTRIAL REPEATERS,” and U.S. Pat. No. 5,103,459, entitled “SYSTEM AND METHOD FOR GENERATING WAVEFORMS IN A CDMA CELLULAR TELEPHONE SYSTEM,” both assigned to the assignee of the present invention, and co-pending U.S. patent application Ser. No. 09/382,438, entitled “METHOD AND APPARATUS USING A MULTI-CARRIER FORWARD LINK IN A WIRELESS COMMUNICATION SYSTEM,” each of which is incorporated by reference herein.

More recently, wireless systems such as the CDMA systems mentioned above have offered hybrid services, such as providing both wireless voice and data communications. To coordinate the implementation of such services, the International Telecommunications Union requested the submission of proposed standards for providing high-rate data and high-quality speech services over wireless communication channels. A preliminary proposal was issued by the Telecommunications Industry Association, entitled “The cdma2000 ITU-R RTT Candidate Submission,” incorporated by reference herein and hereafter referred to as cdma2000. Various methods for transmitting non-voice data over fundamental and supplemental channels are disclosed in cdma2000.

In a CDMA system, a user communicates with the network through one or more base stations. For example, a user on a remote station (RS) may communicate with a land-based data source, such as the Internet, by transmitting data to a base station (BS) via a wireless link. This link between the RS and the BS is commonly referred to as the “reverse link.” The BS receives the data and routes it through a base station controller (BSC) to the land-based data network. When data is transmitted from the BS to the RS, it is transmitted on the “forward link.” In CDMA IS-95 systems, the forward link (FL) and the reverse link (RL) are allocated to separate frequencies.

The remote station communicates with at least one base station during a communication. However, CDMA RSs are also capable of communicating with multiple BSs simultaneously, such as during soft handoff. Soft handoff is a process of establishing a new forward and reverse link with a new base station before breaking the old links with the previous base station. Soft handoff minimizes the probability of dropped calls, that is, where a call is inadvertently disconnected from the system. A method and apparatus for providing communications between an RS and more than one BS during the soft handoff process is disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 5,267,261, entitled “MOBILE ASSISTED SOFT HANDOFF IN A CDMA CELLULAR TELEPHONE SYSTEM,” assigned to the assignee of the present invention and incorporated by reference herein.

Given the growing demand for wireless data applications, the need for very efficient voice and data wireless communication systems has become increasingly significant. One method for transmitting data in code channel frames of fixed size is described in detail in U.S. Pat. No. 5,504,773, entitled “METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR THE FORMATTING OF DATA FOR TRANSMISSION,” assigned to the assignee of the present invention and incorporated by reference herein. In accordance with the IS-95 standard, non-voice data or voice data is partitioned into code channel frames that are 20 msec wide with data rates as high as 14.4 kbps.

A significant difference between voice services and data services is the fact that voice services have stringent fixed delay requirements. Typically, the overall one-way delay of voice services must be less than 100 msec. In contrast, selectively planned data service delays, even above 100 msec, can be used to optimize the efficiency of the communication system. For example, error correction coding techniques that require relatively long delays can be used with data service transmissions.

Some parameters that measure the quality and effectiveness of data transmissions are the transmission delay required for transferring a data packet, and the average throughput rate of the system. As explained above, a transmission delay does not have the same impact in data or “non-voice” communication as it does for a voice or “voice-data” communication. Still, delays cannot be ignored because they are an important metric for measuring the quality of the data communication system. The average throughput rate is reflective of the efficiency of the data transmission capability of the communication system.

Further, in a wireless communication system, capacity is maximized when the transmission energy for a signal is kept to a minimum value while satisfying the quality performance requirements for the signal. That is, the quality of transmitted voice-data or non-voice data cannot be significantly degraded when received. One measure of the quality of a received signal is the carrier-to-interference ratio (C/I) at the receiver. Thus, it is desirable to provide a transmission power control system that maintains a constant C/I at a receiver. Such a system is described in detail in U.S. Pat. No. 5,056,109 entitled “Method and Apparatus for Controlling Transmission Power in a CDMA Cellular Telephone System,” assigned to the assignee of the present invention and incorporated by reference herein.

It is well known that in cellular systems the C/I of any given user is a function of the location of the RS within a coverage area. In order to maintain a given level of service, TDMA and FDMA systems resort to frequency reuse techniques, i.e. not all frequency channels and/or time slots are used in each base station. In a CDMA system, the same frequency channel allocation is reused in every cell of the system, thereby improving the overall efficiency. The C/I associated with an RS determines the information rate that can be supported on the forward link from the base station to the user's RS. An exemplary system for transmitting high rate digital data in a wireless communication system is disclosed in issued U.S. Pat. No. 6,574,211, entitled “METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR HIGHER RATE PACKET DATA TRANSMISSION,” issued Jun. 3, 2003, assigned to the assignee of the present application and incorporated by reference herein.

Because the C/I associated with a RS determines the information rate that can be supported on the forward link, it is useful to know transmission information for each frequency channel used and historic C/I information. This information is commonly collected at the RS and messaged to the BS. But this messaging uses valuable system resources. What is needed is an invention that would eliminate such messaging requirements. Preferably, the BS transmission power levels on a first channel would be used to predict favorable slots for transmitting additional data on a second channel.

It is well known in the art that knowledge of a communication channel can be used to increase capacity in a CDMA system by transmitting mostly at times when channel conditions are good. See, e.g., S. W. Kim & A. Goldsmith, “Truncated Power Control in Code Division Multiple Access Communications,” Globecom (1997); R. Knopp & P. Humblet, “Multiple-Accessing over Frequency-Selective Fading Channels,” PIMRC (1995); A. Goldsmith & P. Varaiya, “Increasing Spectral Efficiency Through Power Control,” ICC (1993). This technique is commonly referred to as “waterfilling.” An issue that arises in cellular or PCS CDMA systems is fairness in that users nearer to a given BS may be favored in a waterfilling approach. Accordingly, there is a tradeoff between total throughput and fairness among users.

An algorithm based on priority given just by the carrier-to-interference ratio (C/I) would always give all the of power to the user close to the BS with the best channel. This would maximize system throughput but be unfair to users that are far from the BS. One solution, recently introduced by D. Tse and entitled “Forward-Link Multiuser Diversity Through Rate Adaptation and Scheduling” (not yet published), attempts to compromise between throughput and fairness by including throughput monitoring that introduces fairness by raising the priority of users who do not transmit overly long. Nevertheless, a need exists in the art to provide an improved forward-link scheduling technique that compromises between fairness and system throughput and is suitable for multiple users.

SUMMARY

Broadly, the present invention solves a new technical challenge posed by the increasing demand for wireless communication services. The invention concerns a method and apparatus for selecting a favored transmission “slot” for non-voice data that is transmitted in conjunction with a voice-data communication. The slot, reflecting a desirable power level and transmission rate for the non-voice data, is selected based upon the transmission power levels for voice-data transmitted by a base station to a remote station.

In one embodiment, the invention may be implemented to provide a method for predicting a favored slot for transmitting non-voice data on a supplemental channel used in a wireless communication system. Generally, metrics reflecting the quality of voice-data signals sent by a base location are measured at a remote station. One or more of the metrics, or a value representing the quality of the received signal, is messaged from the remote station to the base location. If desirable, the base location may adjust the voice-data transmission power in consideration of the messages or values. Concurrently, the forward link voice-data transmission power levels are monitored at the base location. The voice-data is transmitted to the remote station using the first channel, more specifically referred to herein as a fundamental channel.

In one embodiment, a dynamic transmission power value is computed using various voice-data transmission power levels transmitted on the first channel. This value is then used to select a desired slot for transmitting additional data. This additional data is transmitted on a second channel such as a supplemental channel, shared or not shared, using a desired transmission power level and data rate for transmitting the additional data.

In another embodiment, the invention provides an article of manufacture containing digital information executable by a digital signal-processing device. In yet another embodiment, the invention yields an apparatus used to practice the methods of the invention. The apparatus may comprise a remote station and at least one base station that has, amongst other things, a transceiver used to communicate information signals to the remote station. Obviously, to receive signals, the remote station also includes a transceiver communicatively coupled to the base station, and possibly satellites where applicable. The apparatus will also include at least one digital data processing apparatus, such as a microprocessor or application specific integrated circuit (ASIC), that is communicatively coupled to the network or one of its component parts.

The invention provides its users with numerous advantages. One advantage is that it allows power control of a supplemental channel to be established based upon the base location transmitted power for voice-data. Another advantage is that the invention reduces system resource costs currently experienced by communication networks. These networks rely on messages received from a remote station regarding the quality of the supplemental channel signal as received at the remote station. Yet another advantage is that the invention allows a favorable transmission slot in any channel carrying non-voice data to be selected using historic base location transmission power levels for voice data. The invention also provides a number of other advantages and benefits that should become even more apparent after reviewing the following detailed descriptions of the invention.

In one aspect of the invention, a method of scheduling transmit rates and transmit powers of data users of a first type of channel on a forward-link of a wireless communication system, the wireless communication system including a plurality of base stations and a plurality of data users, each data user configured to communicate with any base station by sending frames to the base station and receiving frames from the base station, is provided. The method advantageously includes the steps of determining an available base station power level at the beginning of a frame; predicting a required transmit power level at the beginning of the frame for each data user; determining transmission rates for each data user that are sustainable with the predicted required transmit power level; generating a priority index for each data user; and controlling an order of transmission for the data users so that the data user having the highest priority index transmits first over the next frame.

In one embodiment the step of generating the priority index for each data user comprises dividing the transmission data rates for each user by a throughput value for each user.

In one embodiment the step of predicting the required transmit power level at the beginning of the frame for each data user comprises predicting transmit power levels for each data user of a second type of channel, wherein all of the data users use the first type of channel and the second type of channel, and multiplying the predicted transmit power levels for the second channel by gain factors to convert the predicted transmit power levels to transmit power levels for the first type of channel.

In one embodiment the step of predicting a required transmit power level at the beginning of the frame for each data user further comprises multiplying the predicted transmit power levels for the first type of channel by a margin value to ensure an appropriate average power over the frame.

In one embodiment the method further comprises allowing another data user to transmit if a sufficient remaining base station power level exists.

In another aspect of the invention, an infrastructure element of a wireless communication system wherein a plurality of infrastructure elements communicate with a plurality of data users by exchanging frames on a first type of channel, is provided. The infrastructure element advantageously includes a processor; and a processor-readable storage medium coupled to the processor and containing a set of instructions executable by the processor to determine an available power level for the infrastructure element at the beginning of a frame, predict a required transmit power level at the beginning of the frame for each data user, determine transmission rates for each data user that are sustainable with the predicted required transmit power level, generate a priority index for each data user, and control an order of transmission for the data users so that the data user having the highest priority index transmits first over the next frame.

In another aspect of the invention, an infrastructure element of a wireless communication system wherein a plurality of infrastructure elements communicate with a plurality of data users by exchanging frames on a first type of channel, is provided. The infrastructure element advantageously includes means for determining an available power level for the infrastructure element at the beginning of a frame; means for predicting a required transmit power level at the beginning of the frame for each data user; means for determining transmission rates for each data user that are sustainable with the predicted required transmit power level; means for generating a priority index for each data user; and means for controlling an order of transmission for the data users so that the data user having the highest priority index transmits first over the next frame.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

The nature, objects, and advantages of the invention will become more apparent to those skilled in the art after considering the following detailed description in connection with the accompanying drawings, in which like reference numerals designate like parts throughout, and wherein:

FIG. 1 illustrates transmission power fluctuations with respect to time in accordance with one embodiment;

FIG. 2 illustrates favorable supplemental channel transmission powers in accordance with one embodiment of the present invention;

FIG. 3 shows a flow chart illustrating an operating sequence in accordance with one embodiment of the present invention;

FIG. 4 a is a block diagram of a general configuration for a mobile station used in accordance with the invention, and FIG. 4 b is a block diagram of a general channel structure used in accordance with one embodiment of the present invention;

FIG. 5 a is a block diagram of the hardware components and interconnections of a digital signal processing apparatus used in accordance with one embodiment of the present invention, and FIG. 5 b is a block diagram of the hardware components and interconnections of the modulator 526 shown in FIG. 5 a and used in accordance with the one embodiment of the present invention;

FIG. 6 a is a block diagram of a portion of the hardware components and interconnections of a digital signal processing base station apparatus used in accordance with one embodiment of the present invention, and FIG. 6 b is a block diagram of the hardware components and interconnections of the demodulator 604 shown in FIG. 6 a and used in accordance with one embodiment of the present invention;

FIG. 7 is an exemplary digital data storage medium in accordance with one embodiment of the present invention;

FIG. 8 is a flow chart illustrating method steps performed by a base station in a wireless communication system to accomplish forward-link scheduling; and

FIG. 9 is a continuous flow chart illustrating in detail method steps performed by a base station in a wireless communication system to accomplish forward-link scheduling.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION

FIGS. 1-9 illustrate examples of the various method and apparatus aspects of the present invention. For ease of explanation, but without any limitation intended, the apparatus examples are described in the context of a signal processing apparatus that may be embodied by various hardware components and interconnections. Further arrangements for these signal processing apparatuses will become apparent to anyone skilled in the art after reading the descriptions that follow.

Operation

IS-95 supports medium data (MDR) transmission of data by allowing a base location (BS) to communicate with a remote station (RS) using up to eight (8) forward links and up to eight (8) reverse links. Further advances have been made allowing for even higher data rate (HDR) transmissions using somewhat similar systems. Generally, data can be more efficiently communicated between a BS and a RS if it is transmitted at the lowest possible power level required for maintaining the quality of the communication.

Transmission of voice-data generally relies on the large number of uncorrelated users communicating with a base station and well-behaved Markov voice statistics to balance both RF capacity and RF stability. These large numbers of uncorrelated users result in a forward link RF transmit power distribution that is predictably stationary and log-normal. Without this forward link RF power predictability, forward link power control and mobile assisted handoff would be unstable.

However, transmission of non-voice data, such as downloading data from the Internet, is not as well behaved. Data traffic often comes in bursts, resulting in relatively long periods of maximum rate transmission followed by relatively long periods of minimum rate transmission. With the advent of MDR and HDR networks, these effects become even more pronounced. Unlike correlated voice links, these links switch between maximum rate and minimum rate together and power control together. This can cause the forward link power distribution as a whole to be decidedly non-stationary and non-log-normal.

In a typical communication network, RS users (users) have different radio frequency (RF) requirements depending upon their location relative to the base station or stations with which they are in communication. The worse a user's RF environment, the more power a base station requires to deliver a fixed amount of data. Therefore, users experiencing a poor RF environment use more network capacity. For example, users in different physical locations will experience different fading conditions, such as a user passing into the RF shadow of a building, whereas another user may be passing into the RF shadow of a tree. These conditions will reduce the strength of the received signals, resulting in a poorer quality received signal than if the fade had not occurred. To overcome fading, transmission power may be increased.

As shown in FIG. 1, the transmission power level for voice-data transmitted from a BS to a RS may vary with time. For example, at time 102 the power level used to transmit voice-data to a user #1 from a BS is at a maximum. At time 104, the power level required to transmit voice-data to a user #2 is at a minimum. At time 106, the average voice-data transmission power level for users #1 and #2 is at a minimum. In one embodiment of the invention, the slot 108 shown in FIG. 2 is a favorable time, or slot, to transmit additional data on the data channel of user #2. This determination is made using the voice-data transmission power levels as measured at the base location. Selecting non-voice data to be transmitted to a user on a second channel based on predicted BS power levels for voice-data transmissions on a first channel maximizes overall data through-put and does not require any quality metric messaging from the RS to the BS regarding the second channel.

This basic method assures that voice-data transmissions are guaranteed: 1) a minimum bandwidth; 2) a maximum delay window; and, 3) a given data rate. However, non-voice data users generally have less stringent communication quality requirements so the transmission data rate can be varied. However, the invention can also be used for solely non-voice data transmissions. In this embodiment, non-voice data is communicated using one or more forward link channels, but having an overall fixed total transmission power. The communication transmits at data rates that ensure the transmission power level is below the total allowable transmission power level. This is accomplished first by using a full-rate fundamental channel and then adding supplemental channels for transmitting. The transmission power used to transmit on the supplemental channels is determined from the transmission power measured at the BS for transmissions on the fundamental channel. Regardless, the transmission power levels for the channels used to transmit the non-voice data aggregate to a value below the total allowable transmission power.

FIG. 3 is a flow chart reflecting method steps 300 for one embodiment of the present invention as used in a CDMA network. The method starts at step 302 and data signals are transmitted in task 304 from a BS to a RS. As discussed above, this transmitted data may comprise voice and/or non-voice data transmitted on a first channel, also referred to herein as a fundamental channel. A first channel is a portion of the Forward Link Channel that carries a combination of higher-level data and power control information from the BS to the RS. A second channel is a portion of the Forward Link Channel that operates in conjunction with the first channel or a forward dedicated control channel to provide increased data delivery services. A second channel is commonly referred to as a supplemental channel, but could be a dedicated fundamental channel.

As voice-data transmissions occur, the RS receiving the transmission measures pre-selected metrics reflective of the quality of the communication received. These metrics can include bit error rate as well as other commonly used metrics. If the quality of the received signal falls off and remains poor, the RS messages a representative value to the BS in task 308. This message may indicate that an increase, decrease, or no change in transmission power for data transmitted on the first channel is required. If necessary, the transmission power level may be adjusted in task 310.

As the BS transmits data on the fundamental channel, the transmission power levels are monitored at the BS in task 312. A dynamic value reflecting the aggregated transmission levels and distributions is determined in task 314. In this embodiment, the dynamic value may reflect the momentary average transmission power level. In other embodiments, the dynamic value may be determined in a multitude of ways known in the art, so long as the dynamic value represents the lowest transmission power value at a selected point in time for first channel transmissions. Using these dynamic values, the most favored slot for transmission of data on a second channel may be predicted in task 316. Non-voice data for a RS user in need of the data may be selected and the data transmitted. If the non-voice data communication is complete, then the method ends in task 320. However, if the communication is not complete, or if a transmissions intended for another user are desired, then the method repeats itself in task 318.

Hardware Components and Interconnections

In addition to the various method embodiments described above, a different aspect of the invention concerns apparatus embodiments used to perform the methods.

FIG. 4 a shows a simple block representation of a mobile station (MS) 401 configured for use in accordance with the present invention. MS 401 receives a signal from a base station (not shown) using a cdma2000 multi-carrier FL. The signal is processed as described below. MS 401 uses a cdma2000 RL to transmit information to the base station. FIG. 4 b shows a more detailed block representation of a channel structure used to prepare information for transmission by MS 401 in accordance with the present invention. In the figure, information to be transmitted, hereafter referred to as a signal, is transmitted in bits organized into blocks of bits. A CRC and tail bit generator (generator) 403 receives the signal. The generator 403 uses a cyclic redundancy code to generate parity check bits to assist in determining the quality of the signal when received by a receiver. These bits are included in the signal. A tail bit—a fixed sequence of bits—may also be added to the end of a block of data to reset an encoder 405 to a known state.

The encoder 405 receives the signal and builds a redundancy into the signal for error-correcting purposes. Different “codes” may be used to determine how the redundancy will be built into the signal. These encoded bits are called symbols. The repetition generator 407 repeats the symbols it receives a predetermined number of times, thus allowing part of the symbols to be lost due to a transmission error without affecting the overall quality of the information being sent. Block interleaver 409 takes the symbols and jumbles them. The long code generator 411 receives the jumbled symbols and scrambles them using a pseudorandom noise sequence generated at a predetermined chip rate. Each symbol is XOR-ed with one of the pseudorandom chips of the scrambling sequence.

The information may be transmitted using more than one carrier (channel) as explained with regards to the method, above. Accordingly, a demultiplexer (not shown) may take an input signal “a” and split it into multiple output signals in such a way that the input signal may be recovered. In one embodiment the signal “a” is split into three separate signals, each signal representing a selected data-type, and is transmitted using one FL channel per data-type signal. In another embodiment, the demultiplexer may split signal “a” into two components per data-type. Regardless of the arrangement, the present invention contemplates that distinct signals generated from a parent signal can be transmitted using one or more channels.

Further, this technique can be applied to multiple users whose signals are transmitted using completely or partially the same FL channels. For example, if the signals from four different users are going to be sent using the same three FL channels, then each of these signals is “channelized” by demultiplexing each signal into three components, where each component will be sent using a different FL channel. For each channel, the respective signals are multiplexed together to form one signal per FL channel. Then, using the technique described herein, the signals are transmitted. The demultiplexed signal is then encoded by a Walsh encoder (not shown) and spread into two components, components I and Q, by a multiplier (also not shown). These components are summed by a summer and communicated to a remote station (not shown).

FIG. 5 a illustrates a functional block diagram of an exemplary embodiment of the transmission system of the present invention embodied in a wireless communication device 500. One skilled in the art will understand that certain functional blocks shown in the figure may not be present in other embodiments of the invention. The block diagram of FIG. 5 b corresponds to an embodiment consistent for operation according to the TIA/EIA Standard IS-95C, also referred to as IS-2000, or cdma2000 for CDMA applications. Other embodiments of the present invention are useful for other standards including the Wideband CDMA (WCDMA) standards proposed by the standards bodies ETSI and ARIB. It will be understood by one skilled in the art that owing to the extensive similarity between the reverse link modulation in the WCDMA standards and the reverse link modulation in the IS-95C standard, extension of the present invention to the WCDMA standards may be accomplished.

In the exemplary embodiment of FIG. 5 a, the wireless communication device transmits a plurality of distinct channels of information which are distinguished from one another by short orthogonal spreading sequences as described in the U.S. patent application Ser. No. 08/886,604, entitled “HIGH DATA RATE CDMA WIRELESS COMMNICATION SYSTEM,” assigned to the assignee of the present invention and incorporated by reference herein. Five separate code channels are transmitted by the wireless communication device: 1) a first supplemental data channel 532, 2) a time multiplexed channel of pilot and power control symbols 534, 3) a dedicated control channel 536, 4) a second supplemental data channel 538 and 5) a fundamental channel 540. The first supplemental data channel 532 and second supplemental data channel 538 carry digital data which exceeds the capacity of the fundamental channel 540 such as facsimile, multimedia applications, video, electronic mail messages or other forms of digital data. The multiplexed channel of pilot and power control symbols 534 carries pilots symbols to allow for coherent demodulation of the data channels by the base station and power control bits to control the energy of transmissions of the base station or base stations in communication with wireless communication device 500. Control channel 536 carries control information to the base station such as modes of operation of wireless communication device 500, capabilities of wireless communication device 500 and other necessary signaling information. Fundamental channel 540 is the channel used to carry primary information from the wireless communication device to the base station. In the case of speech transmissions, the fundamental channel 540 carries the speech data.

Supplemental data channels 532 and 538 are encoded and processed for transmission by means not shown and provided to modulator 526. Power control bits are provided to repetition generator 522, which provides repetition of the power control bits before providing the bits to multiplexer (MUX) 524. In MUX 524 the redundant power control bits are time multiplexed with pilot symbols and provided on line 534 to modulator 526.

Message generator 512 generates necessary control information messages and provides the control message to CRC and tail bit generator 514. CRC and tail bit generator 514 appends a set of cyclic redundancy check bits which are parity bits used to check the accuracy of the decoding at the base station and appends a predetermined set of tail bits to the control message to clear the memory of the decoder at the base station receiver subsystem. The message is then provided to encoder 516, which provides forward error correction coding upon the control message. The encoded symbols are provided to repetition generator 518, which repeats the encoded symbols to provide additional time diversity in the transmission. The symbols are then provided to interleaver 520, which reorders the symbols in accordance with a predetermined interleaving format. The interleaved symbols are provided on line 536 to modulator 526.

Variable rate data source 502 generates variable rate data. In the exemplary embodiment, variable rate data source 502 is a variable rate speech encoder such as described in U.S. Pat. No. 5,414,796, entitled “VARIABLE RATE VOCODER,” assigned to the assignee of the present invention and incorporated by reference herein. Variable rate vocoders are popular in wireless communications because their use increases the battery life of wireless communication devices and increases system capacity with minimal impact on perceived speech quality. The Telecommunications Industry Association has codified the most popular variable rate speech encoders in such standards as Interim Standard IS-96 and Interim Standard IS-733. These variable rate speech encoders encode the speech signal at four possible rates referred to as full rate, half rate, quarter rate, or eighth rate according to the level of voice activity. The rate indicates the number of bits used to encode a frame of speech and varies on a frame by frame basis. Full rate uses a predetermined maximum number of bits to encode the frame, half rate uses half the predetermined maximum number of bits to encode the frame, quarter rate uses one quarter the predetermined maximum number of bits to encode the frame and eighth rate uses one eighth the predetermined maximum number of bits to encode the frame.

Variable rate date source 502 provides the encoded speech frame to CRC and tail bit generator 504. CRC and tail bit generator 504 appends a set of cyclic redundancy check bits which are parity bits used to check the accuracy of the decoding at the base station and appends a predetermined set of tail bits to the control message in order to clear the memory of the decoder at the base station. The frame is then provided to encoder 506, which provides forward error correction coding on the speech frame. The encoded symbols are provided to repetition generator 508, which provides repetition of the encoded symbol. The symbols are then provided to interleaver 510 and reordered in accordance with a predetermined interleaving format. The interleaved symbols are provided on line 540 to modulator 526.

In the exemplary embodiment, modulator 526 modulates the data channels in accordance with a code division multiple access modulation format and provides the modulated information to transmitter (TMTR) 530, which amplifies and filters the signal and provides the signal through duplexer 528 for transmission through an antenna 530. In IS-95 and cdma2000 systems, a 20 ms frame is divided into sixteen sets of equal numbers of symbols, referred to as power control groups. The reference to power control is based on the fact that for each power control group, the base station receiving the frame issues a power control command in response to a determination of the sufficiency of the received reverse link signal at the base station.

FIG. 5 b illustrates a functional block diagram of an exemplary embodiment of modulator 526 of FIG. 5 a. The first supplemental data channel data is provided on line 532 to spreading element 542 which covers the supplemental channel data in accordance with a predetermined spreading sequence. In the exemplary embodiment, spreading element 542 spreads the supplemental channel data with a short Walsh sequence (++−−). The spread data is provided to relative gain element 544, which adjusts the gain of the spread supplemental channel data relative to the energy of the pilot and power control symbols. The gain adjusted supplemental channel data is provided to a first summing input of summing element 546. The pilot and power control multiplexed symbols are provided on line 534 to a second summing input of summing element 546.

Control channel data is provided on line 536 to spreading element 548 which covers the supplemental channel data in accordance with a predetermined spreading sequence. In the exemplary embodiment, spreading element 548 spreads the supplemental channel data with a short Walsh sequence (++++++++−−−−−−−−). The spread data is provided to relative gain element 550, which adjusts the gain of the spread control channel data relative to the energy of the pilot and power control symbols. The gain adjusted control data is provided to a third summing input of summing element 546. Summing element 546 sums the gain adjusted control data symbols, the gain adjusted supplemental channel symbols, and the time multiplexed pilot and power control symbols and provides the sum to a first input of multiplier 562 and a first input of multiplier 568.

The second supplemental channel is provided on line 538 to spreading element 552 which covers the supplemental channel data in accordance with a predetermined spreading sequence. In the exemplary embodiment, spreading element 552 spreads the supplemental channel data with a short Walsh sequence (++−−). The spread data is provided to relative gain element 554, which adjusts the gain of the spread supplemental channel data. The gain adjusted supplemental channel data is provided to a first summing input of summer 556.

The fundamental channel data is provided on line 540 to spreading element 558, which covers the fundamental channel data in accordance with a predetermined spreading sequence. In the exemplary embodiment, spreading element 558 spreads the fundamental channel data with a short Walsh sequence (++++−−−−++++−−−−). The spread data is provided to relative gain element 560, which adjusts the gain of the spread fundamental channel data. The gain adjusted fundamental channel data is provided to a second summing input of summing element 556. Summing element 556 sums the gain adjusted second supplemental channel data symbols and the fundamental channel data symbols and provides the sum to a first input of multiplier 564 and a first input of multiplier 566.

In the exemplary embodiment, a pseudonoise spreading using two different short PN sequences (PNI and PNQ) is used to spread the data. In the exemplary embodiment the short PN sequences, PNI and PNQ, are multiplied by a long PN code to provide additional privacy. The generation of pseudonoise sequences is well known in the art and is described in detail in U.S. Pat. No. 5,103,459, entitled “SYSTEM AND METHOD FOR GENERATING SIGNAL WAVEFORMS IN A CDMA CELLULAR TELEPHONE SYSTEM,” assigned to the assignee of the present invention and incorporated by reference herein. A long PN sequence is provided to a first input of multipliers 570 and 572. The short PN sequence PNI is provided to a second input of multiplier 570 and the short PN sequence PNQ is provided to a second input of multiplier 572.

The resulting PN sequence from multiplier 570 is provided to respective second inputs of multipliers 562 and 564. The resulting PN sequence from multiplier 572 is provided to respective second inputs of multipliers 566 and 568. The product sequence from multiplier 562 is provided to the summing input of subtractor 574. The product sequence from multiplier 564 is provided to a first summing input of summing element 576. The product sequence from multiplier 566 is provided to the subtracting input of subtractor 574. The product sequence from multiplier 568 is provided to a second summing input of summing element 576.

The difference sequence from subtractor 574 is provided to baseband filter 578. Baseband filter 578 performs necessary filtering on the difference sequence and provides the filtered sequence to gain element 582. Gain element 582 adjusts the gain of the signal and provides the gain-adjusted signal to upconverter 586. Upconverter 586 upconverts the gain adjusted signal in accordance with a QPSK modulation format and provides the upconverted signal to a first input of summing element 590.

The sum sequence from summing element 576 is provided to baseband filter 580. Baseband filter 580 performs necessary filtering on the difference sequence and provides the filtered sequence to gain element 584. Gain element 584 adjusts the gain of the signal and provides the gain-adjusted signal to upconverter 588. Upconverter 588 upconverts the gain adjusted signal in accordance with a QPSK modulation format and provides the upconverted signal to a second input of summing element 590. Summing element 590 sums the two QPSK modulated signals and provides the result to a transmitter (not shown).

Turning now to FIG. 6 a, a functional block diagram of selected portions of a base station 600 is shown in accordance with one embodiment of the present invention. Reverse-link RF signals from the wireless communication device 500 (FIG. 5 b) are received by receiver (RCVR) 602, which downconverts the received reverse-link RF signals to a baseband frequency. In the exemplary embodiment, receiver 602 downconverts the received signal in accordance with a QPSK demodulation format. Demodulator 604 then demodulates the baseband signal. Demodulator 604 is further described with reference to FIG. 6 b below.

The demodulated signal is provided to accumulator 606. Accumulator 606 sums the symbol energies of the redundantly transmitted power control groups of symbols. The accumulated symbol energies are provided to deinterleaver 608 and reordered in accordance with a predetermined de-interleaving format. The reordered symbols are provided to decoder 610 and decoded to provide an estimate of the transmitted frame. The estimate of the transmitted frame is then provided to CRC check 613, which determines the accuracy of the frame estimate based on the CRC bits included in the transmitted frame.

In the exemplary embodiment, base station 600 performs a blind decoding on the reverse-link signal. Blind decoding describes a method of decoding variable rate data in which the receiver does not know a priori the rate of the transmission. In the exemplary embodiment, base station 600 accumulates, deinterleaves, and decodes the data in accordance with each possible rate hypothesis. The frame selected as the best estimate is based on quality metrics such as the symbol error rate, the CRC check, and the Yamamoto metric.

An estimate of the frame for each rate hypothesis is provided to control processor 617 and a set of quality metrics for each of the decoded estimates is also provided. These quality metrics may include the symbol error rate, the Yamamoto metric, and the CRC check. Control processor 617 selectively provides one of the decoded frames to the remote station user or declares a frame erasure.

In the preferred embodiment, demodulator 604 shown in FIG. 6 a has one demodulation chain for each information channel. An exemplary demodulator 604 performs complex demodulation on signals modulated by an exemplary modulator. As previously described, receiver (RCVR) 602 downconverts the received reverse-link RF signals to a baseband frequency, producing Q and I baseband signals. Despreaders 614 and 616 respectively despread the I and Q baseband signals using the long code from FIG. 5 a. Baseband filters (BBF) 618 and 620, respectively, filter the I and Q baseband signals.

Despreaders 622 and 624, respectively, despread the I and Q signals using the PNI sequence of FIG. 5 b. Similarly, despreaders 626 and 628, respectively, despread the Q and I signals using the PNQ sequence of FIG. 5 b. The outputs of despreaders 622 and 624 are combined in combiner 630. The output of despreader 628 is subtracted from the output of despreader 624 in combiner 632. The respective outputs of combiners 630 and 632 are then Walsh-uncovered in Walsh-uncoverers 634 and 636 with the Walsh code that was used to cover the particular channel of interest in FIG. 5 b. The respective outputs of the Walsh-uncoverers 634 and 636 are then summed over one Walsh symbol by accumulators 642 and 644.

The respective outputs of combiners 630 and 632 are also summed over one Walsh symbol by accumulators 638 and 640. The respective outputs of accumulators 638 and 640 are then applied to pilot filters 646 and 648. Pilot filters 646 and 648 generate an estimation of the channel conditions by determining the estimated gain and phase of the pilot signal data 534 (see FIG. 5 a). The output of pilot filter 646 is then complex multiplied by the respective outputs of accumulators 642 and 644 in complex multipliers 650 and 652. Similarly, the output of pilot filter 648 is complex multiplied by the respective outputs of accumulators 642 and 644 in complex multipliers 654 and 656. The output of complex multiplier 654 is then summed with the output of complex multiplier 650 in combiner 658. The output of complex multiplier 656 is subtracted from the output of complex multiplier 652 in combiner 660. Finally, the outputs of combiners 558 and 660 are combined in combiner 662 to produce the demodulated signal of interest.

Despite the specific foregoing descriptions, ordinarily skilled artisans having the benefit of this disclosure will recognize that the apparatus discussed above may be implemented in a machine of different construction without departing from the scope of the present invention. Similarly, parallel methods may be developed. As a specific apparatus example, one of the components such as summing element 622, shown in FIG. 6 b, may be combined with summing element 626 even though they are shown as separate elements in the functional diagram.

Signal-Bearing Media

The methods described above may be implemented, for example, by operating a base station to execute a sequence of machine-readable instructions. These instructions may reside in various types of signal bearing media. In this respect, one embodiment of the invention concerns a programmed product, or article of manufacture, comprising signal-bearing media tangibly embodying a program of machine-readable instructions executable by a digital signal processor to perform the methods discussed above.

The signal bearing media may comprise any type of digital data storage media. An exemplary digital data storage medium is shown in FIG. 7. Other exemplary storage media may comprise an application specific integrated circuit (ASIC), a digital data or optical storage device accessible by the base station, electronic read-only memory, or other suitable signal bearing media. In an illustrative embodiment of the invention, the machine-readable instructions may comprise software object code, compiled from a language such as C, C+, C++, or other coding language.

Forward-Link Scheduling Algorithm

In one embodiment a BS (not shown) is configured to perform the method steps illustrated in the flow chart of FIG. 8 to accomplish forward-link scheduling in a wireless communication system. The following conditions may be applied in accordance with a specific embodiment: (1) There are N supplemental channel (SCH) data users, each associated with a fundamental channel (FCH); the SCH active set=1, and the FCH active set≧1; (3) a Turbo decoder is used for the SCH and a convolutional decoder is used for the FCH; (4) blind rate determination is used for SCH users to determine up to three rates (as needed for fast prediction); (5) a predictor is available at the BS (although not in a system simulation) to predict the required FCH power at the beginning of a frame; (6) the power available for data users P_(α)=P_(max)−ΣFCH power−ΣOther powers where P_(max) is the total power, and Other powers are overhead power levels (e.g., for the pilot channel, the paging channel, the sync channel, and the control channel (CCH)); (7) after the powers and the rates of transmitted users are determined using margins, the powers are increased proportionally to use all of the available power P_(α); (8) a system simulator should include frame timing, fading changes at every frame, individual queues for data users, and FCH power required for each frame.

In step 700 the BS initializes the user throughput, TI(0). The BS then proceeds to step 702. In step 702 the BS obtains input parameters for the kth frame. The BS then proceeds to step 704. In step 704 the BS calculates the potential SCH rate, R_(i)(k), and priority index, I_(i)(k), for each data user. The BS then proceeds to step 706. In step 706 the BS calculates the actual SCH transmit rate for each user, assuming S={1,2, . . . , N}, P_(r)(k)=P_(α)(k) where P_(r)(k)=remaining power available, and S is the new user set. The BS then proceeds to step 708. In step 708 the BS sets the transmit rate and the transmit power, and updates the user throughput, Ti (k). The BS then returns to step 702. The iterations continue until all of the frames are processed.

In accordance with a particular embodiment, the algorithm steps taken by the BS in FIG. 8 are described in greater detail with reference to the flow chart of FIG. 9. In step 800 of FIG. 9, a BS (not shown) initializes the user throughput by setting TI(0) equal to 9.6 kbps for i=1,2, . . . ,N, where i is an index specifying the user number, and N is the total number of users. In another embodiment the user throughput is initialized to 14.4 kbps. The BS then proceeds to step 802.

In steps 802-806 the BS obtains the input parameters of the kth frame. In step 802 the BS calculates the total power available for data users, P_(α)(k). The total power available to data users may advantageously be calculated by subtracting both the sum of the fundamental channel power levels and the sum of all other, or overhead, power levels (e.g., power levels for the pilot channel, paging channel, sync channel, and control channel) from the maximum power for the BS (which is advantageously fixed). The BS then proceeds to step 804. In step 804 the BS obtains the FCH transmit power, P_(i) ^(F)(k), of frame k of each data user i, where i=1,2, . . . ,N, there being N users. The FCH power level is advantageously obtained by integrating the power control groups in each frame over time for a number of previous frames and then predicting the instantaneous power required for the kth frame, as specified in cdma2000. The BS then proceeds to step 806. In step 806 the BS obtains the FCH transmit rate, of frame k of each data user i, for i=1,2, . . . ,N. The transmit rate is advantageously fixed during a data call, and may be either full rate (e.g., 9.6 kbps or 14.4 kbps), half rate, quarter rate, or eighth rate, as specified in cdma2000. The BS then proceeds to step 808.

In steps 808-810 the BS calculates the possible SCH rate, R_(i)(k), and the priority index, I_(i)(k), for each data user. In step 808 the BS determines the possible SCH rate for each user in accordance with the following equation: ${{R_{i}(k)} = {\frac{{R_{i}^{F}(k)}{P_{a}(k)}}{{P_{i\quad}^{F}(k)}\alpha_{P\quad M}\alpha_{ASM}}\left( \frac{P_{CC}}{P_{TC}} \right)}},\left( {{i = 1},2,\quad\ldots\quad,N} \right),$

-   -   where P_(TC) is the power needed to transmit data at rate R_(i)         ^(F)(k) with a Turbo decoder, and P_(CC) is the power needed to         transmit data at rate R_(i) ^(F)(k) with a convolutional         decoder. The values PTC and PCC are advantageously derived         through simulations and stored in a lookup table in the BS prior         to operation. The value α_(PM) is the transmit power prediction         margin, which is advantageously greater than one. The value         α_(ASM) is the active set margin, which is advantageously         greater than one (while the FCH active set is greater than one,         allowing one or more BSs to be in simultaneous communication         with a user for a voice call, the SCH is equal to one,         restricting data calls from a user to just one BS). The BS then         proceeds to step 810. In step 810 the BS determines the priority         index for each user in accordance with the following equation:         I _(i)(k)=R _(i)(k)/(T _(i)(k),(i=1,2, . . . ,N)

The BS then proceeds to step 812.

In steps 812-830 the BS calculates the actual SCH transmit rate, R*_(j)(k), for each user, j, assuming S={1,2, . . . ,N} and P_(r)(k)=P_(α)(k), where P_(r)(k)=remaining power available, and S is the new user set. In step 812 the BS lets ${I_{j}(k)} = {\max\limits_{i \in S}\left\{ {I_{i}(k)} \right\}}$ and fits R_(j)(k) to a number of available rates (r₁<r₂, . . . ,<r_(M)) such that r_(l)≦R_(j)(k)<r_(l+1). The number of rates could be any number of rates as negotiated between the BS and the data user via a signaling channel. In a particular embodiment the number of available rates is three. The BS then proceeds to step 814. In step 814 the BS determines whether R_(j)(k)<r₁. If Rj(k) is less than r1, the BS proceeds to step 816. If, on the other hand, Rj(k) is not less than r1, the BS proceeds to step 818. In step 816 the BS sets the actual transmit rate for user j, R*_(j)(k), equal to zero. In step 818 the BS determines whether R_(j)(k)>r_(M). If R_(j)(k) is greater than rM, the BS proceeds to step 820. If, on the other hand, R_(j)(k) is not greater than rM, the BS proceeds to step 822. In step 820 the BS sets the actual transmit rate for user j, R*_(j)(k), equal to rM. In step 822 the BS sets the actual transmit rate for user j, R*_(j)(k), equal to r1. The BS then proceeds to step 824.

In step 824 the BS updates the remaining power available, Pr(k), in accordance with the following equation: ${P_{r}(k)} = {{P_{r}(k)} - {\frac{{R_{j}^{*}(k)}{P_{j}^{F}(k)}\alpha_{P\quad M}\alpha_{ASM}}{R_{j}^{F}(k)}{\left( \frac{P_{CC}}{P_{TC}} \right)^{- 1}.}}}$

The BS then proceeds to step 826. In step 826 the BS updates the new user set, S, by subtracting user j from the user set, S. The BS then proceeds to step 828. In step 828 the BS updates the new transmit rate, R_(i)(k) in accordance with the following equation: ${{R_{i}(k)} = {\frac{{R_{i}^{F}(k)}{P_{a}(k)}}{{P_{i\quad}^{F}(k)}\alpha_{P\quad M}\alpha_{ASM}}\left( \frac{P_{CC}}{P_{TC}} \right)}},{i \in {S.}}$

The BS then proceeds to step 830. In step 830 the BS determines whether the user set, S, is not equal to zero. If the user set, S, is not the empty set, φ, the BS returns to step 812 to begin an iteration through steps 812 to 830 to calculate the actual SCH transmit rate for the next user R*_(j)(k), for the next user, j. If, on the other hand, the user set, S, is the empty set, φ, the BS proceeds to step 832.

In steps 832-836 the BS sets the transmit rate and the transmit power for each user, and updates the user throughput, Ti(k), for the kth frame. In step 832 the BS transmits data at the rate R*_(i)(k), (i=1,2, . . . , N). The BS then proceeds to step 834. In step 834 the BS updates the transmit power for user i in accordance with the following equation: ${{P_{i\quad}^{*}(k)} = {\frac{P_{i\quad}(k)}{\sum\limits_{j}{P_{j}(k)}}{P_{a}(k)}}},{where}$ ${P_{i}(k)} = {\frac{{R_{j}^{*}(k)}{P_{j}^{F}(k)}\alpha_{P\quad M}\alpha_{ASM}}{R_{j}^{F}(k)}{\left( \frac{P_{CC}}{P_{TC}} \right)^{- 1}.}}$

The BS then proceeds to step 836. In step 836 the BS updates the user throughput, Ti(k), for the kth frame, in accordance with the following equation: T _(i)(k)=(1−1/t)T _(i)(k)+R* _(i)(k)/t

-   -   where t is the window size in number of frames. The BS then         returns to step 802 to begin processing the next frame.

Thus, a novel and improved method and apparatus for performing forward-link scheduling in a wireless communication system have been described. In accordance with the above-described embodiments, the available power in a BS is used for forward-link data calls after accommodating voice traffic. Total system throughput is balanced with fairness in a proportional fairness implementation. A sustainable data rate is advantageously predicted in the BS. The transmit power of the FCH is advantageously multiplied by gain factors for the SCH in accordance with an exemplary embodiment. Multiple users may transmit simultaneously until all the available power is used.

As understood by those of skill, other channels such as, e.g., the DCCH control channel, as specified in cdma2000, may be used instead of the FCH in alternate embodiments. Accordingly, for example, the transmit power of the DCCH (which is convolutionally encoded) is multiplied by an appropriate gain factor for the SCH (which is Turbo encoded).

Those of skill in the art would understand that the various illustrative logical blocks, modules, circuits, and algorithm steps described in connection with the embodiments disclosed herein may be implemented as electronic hardware, computer software, or combinations of both. The various illustrative components, blocks, modules, circuits, and steps have been described generally in terms of their functionality. Whether the functionality is implemented as hardware or software depends upon the particular application and design constraints imposed on the overall system. Skilled artisans recognize the interchangeability of hardware and software under these circumstances, and how best to implement the described functionality for each particular application. As examples, the various illustrative logical blocks, modules, circuits, and algorithm steps described in connection with the embodiments disclosed herein may be implemented or performed with a digital signal processor (DSP), an application specific integrated circuit (ASIC), a field programmable gate array (FPGA) or other programmable logic device, discrete gate or transistor logic, discrete hardware components such as, e.g., registers and FIFO, a processor executing a set of firmware instructions, any conventional programmable software module and a processor, or any combination thereof. The processor may advantageously be a microprocessor, but in the alternative, the processor may be any conventional processor, controller, microcontroller, or state machine. The software module could reside in RAM memory, flash memory, ROM memory, EPROM memory, EEPROM memory, registers, hard disk, a removable disk, a CD-ROM, or any other form of storage medium known in the art. Those of skill would further appreciate that the data, instructions, commands, information, signals, bits, symbols, and chips that may be referenced throughout the above description are advantageously represented by voltages, currents, electromagnetic waves, magnetic fields or particles, optical fields or particles, or any combination thereof.

Other Embodiments

While there have been shown what are presently considered to be exemplary embodiments of the invention, it will be apparent to those skilled in the art that various changes and modifications can be made without departing from the scope of the invention as defined by the appended claims. 

1. A scheduling method, comprising: initializing a user throughput at a first rate; obtaining input parameters for a common frame of each data user; determining, for each data user, a potential transmit rate on a first type of channel and priority index associated with the frame; and determining, for each data user, an actual transmit rate on the first type of channel based on remaining power available.
 2. The method of claim 1, further comprising: setting a transmit rate and a transmit power for each data user.
 3. The method of claim 2, further comprising: updating the user throughput for the frame.
 4. The method of claim 1, wherein the first type of channel comprises a supplemental channel (SCH), and wherein each data user can receive data on the supplemental channel.
 5. The method of claim 1, wherein the first type of channel is associated with a fundamental channel (FCH).
 6. The method of claim 1, wherein obtaining input parameters for a frame, comprises: determining the total power available for data users, by subtracting both the sum of the fundamental channel power levels and the sum of overhead power levels from maximum power; obtaining the FCH transmit power of the common frame of each data user by integrating the power control groups in each frame over time for a number of previous frames and then predicting the instantaneous power required for the common frame; obtaining the FCH transmit rate, of the common frame of each data user.
 7. The method of claim 6, wherein the first type of channel is a supplemental channel, and wherein determining, for each data user, a potential transmit rate on a first type of channel and priority index associated with the frame, comprises: determining, for each data user, a possible SCH rate, and a priority index.
 8. The method of claim 7, wherein determining, for each data user, a possible SCH rate, and a priority index, comprises: determining the possible SCH rate for each data user based on the power needed to transmit data at the FCH transmit rate with a Turbo decoder, and the power needed to transmit data at the FCH transmit rate with a convolutional decoder; and determining the priority index for each user based on a possible SCH rate and the user throughput.
 9. The method of claim 8, wherein determining, for each data user, an actual transmit rate on the first type of channel based on remaining power available, comprises: fitting an actual SCH transmit rate to a number of available rates comprising a first available rate and a second available rate; and determining whether the actual SCH transmit rate is less than the first available rate.
 10. The method of claim 9, further comprising: if the actual SCH transmit rate is less than the first available rate, setting the actual transmit rate equal to approximately zero.
 11. The method of claim 9, further comprising: if the actual SCH transmit rate is not less than the first available rate, determining whether the actual SCH transmit rate is greater than a maximum available rate. If the actual SCH transmit rate is greater than the maximum available rate, setting the actual transmit rate equal to the maximum available rate. The BS then proceeds to step
 824. 12. The method of claim 11, further comprising: updating the remaining power available.
 13. The method of claim 12, further comprising: updating a new user set by subtracting at least one user from the previous user set.
 14. The method of claim 13, further comprising: updating the new transmit rate.
 15. The method of claim 9, wherein the remaining power available equals the total power available. 